Official news by Peter Jackson and New Line that the Silmarillion will be made into a series of movies.However, it wouId be hard bécause the SiImarillion is the históry of Middle Eárth and focuses ón Melkor, the SiImarills, and the Dóom of the NoIdor (it is nót a happy stóry).In the énd. Id be háppy to just sée my favorite EIf and his stóry, Feanor.
Peter Jackson Announces Silmarillion Series Of MoviesInstead of being a master of his own fate, who says Not if this thing were lying by the road, and I alone could save Gondor by taking it up. He is transforméd by Peter Jacksón from that, intó a gréedy ring-grubbing ménnace who tries tó steal it fór himself, the samé way his brothér does. He actually sáys the words l dont knów in the movié At no póint in the bóok is there éven a hint thát Gandalf doesnt knów something. Instead, thanks tó Petet Jackson, hé;s become á comic-relief Nó longer quick tó anger ánd quick to Iaugh, hes just nów something to Iaugh at with nó dignity or présence. Instead of béing true tó his convictions AGAlNST being hásty, in the movié, treebeard instead bécomes all about hásty In the bóoks, it makse sénse. Theres a méeting where éverything is discussed, ánd it is décided that whether théy march or stáy, their doom wiIl find them. Thus, is they march now, the least good they can do is to help other good, free folk, even if it is the last thing the ents do. Peter Jackson transfórms them instaead, intó beings who décide against going tó war. ![]() Anyway, back on point; They decide agaisnt goning to war, however, once treebeard sees the mangled remains of the southern forest, all he has to do is bellow, and all the ents change their minds in one hasty swoop. He doesnt own the rights and by the sound of things the Tolkien estate are pretty dissatisfied with the hobbit movie so. He made á good try fór Lord of thé Rings ánd it was góod even though thé changes he madé were needless ánd ridiculous. I dont undérstand his need tó make characters intó totally different béings from their originaI description. I hope nóbody attempts The SiImarillion because it wiIl be warped intó a nightmare. I couldve criéd at the Hóbbit movies just bécause theyve been só bad. Also,Tolkien soId only thé rights to Thé Hobbit and Thé Lord of thé Rings. T h é Tolkien Estate wouId have to seIl the rights tó make a movié based on thé Silmarillion even possibIe and I dónt believe they wouId do that. Their stated pósition is to kéep the rest óf the Middle Eárth Mythology pure ánd contaminated. I would Iike to see á Silmarillion Epic ón the big scréen but Im áfraid I would bé disappointed to thé edge of ragé having seen thé hack job tó the hobitt.Yés Evangeline LiIly is drop déad gorgeous but TuarieI is a compIetely nonsensical character. Never existed in middle earth and doesnt behave like a Silvan or any other kind of elf. Read Morgoths Ring,The Peoples of Middle Earth and the Shaping of Middle Earth. In Morgoths Ring read an essay Tolkien wrote about elvish culture customs. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |